Current:Home > BackJudge says $475,000 award in New Hampshire youth center abuse case would be ‘miscarriage of justice’-InfoLens
Judge says $475,000 award in New Hampshire youth center abuse case would be ‘miscarriage of justice’
View Date:2024-12-23 10:53:24
CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — The judge who oversaw a landmark trial over abuse at New Hampshire’s youth detention center says capping the verdict at $475,000 as the state proposes would be an “unconscionable miscarriage of justice.”
In a lengthy order issued Wednesday, Judge Andrew Schulman outlined five options for addressing the dispute that arose after a jury awarded $38 million to a man who said he was beaten and raped hundreds of times at the Youth Development Center but found the state liable for only one incident of abuse. Jurors weren’t told that state law caps claims against the state at $475,000 per “incident,” and some later said they wrote “one” to reflect a single case of post-traumatic stress disorder resulting from more than 100 episodes of physical, sexual and emotional abuse.
“The cognitive dissonance between a $38 million verdict and the finding of a ‘single incident’ of actionable abuse cannot stand,” wrote Schulman, who acknowledged that he should have instructed the jury more clearly.
Schulman already has rejected what he called the two worst options: reconvening the jury or questioning them about their decision. The latter would mean no verdict would have finality because jurors could upend them based on little more than “buyer’s remorse,” he wrote.
He appeared equally against the third option, granting the state’s motion to apply the damages cap to the single “incident” found by the jury.
“There was plainly more than one incident,” he wrote. “Entering a verdict of $475,000, when the only proper verdict is many multiples of that number would be a gross and unconscionable miscarriage of justice.”
That leaves two options: ordering a new trial or adjusting the number of incidents on the verdict form. Schulman said a new trial would be a “legally correct” but extremely burdensome choice that could delay justice not only for the plaintiff, David Meehan, but the more than 1,100 other former residents of the youth center who have filed similar lawsuits. He also noted that another monthlong trial could be harmful to Meehan’s mental health.
“The least incorrect” option, Schulman said, might be something akin to a process by which a judge can add damages to an original amount awarded by the jury if a defendant waives a new trial. He calculated that the lowest reasonable number of incidents was 155 and proposed reducing that by 25% as a “large deliberate error” in the state’s favor.
“Although the determination of witness credibility is not the court’s to make, in the court’s eyes, the plaintiff was a most credible witness,” he wrote. “No reasonable jury could have accepted the gist of plaintiff’s testimony, awarded $38 million in damages, and found less than 116 incidents.”
Meehan, 42, went to police in 2017 and sued the state three years later. Since then, 11 former state workers have been arrested though charges against one of them were dropped after he was found incompetent to stand trial.
Over the four-week trial, Meehan’s attorneys argued that the state encouraged a culture of abuse marked by pervasive brutality, corruption and a code of silence. The state, which portrayed Meehan as a violent child, troublemaking teenager and delusional adult, argued that he waited too long to sue and that it shouldn’t be held liable for the actions of “rogue” employees.
A hearing on the verdict dispute is scheduled for next month.
veryGood! (3)
Related
- Gold is suddenly not so glittery after Trump’s White House victory
- The Bachelorette's Rachel Lindsay Breaks Silence on Bryan Abasolo Divorce
- Here's how to smoke ribs or brisket in your kitchen: GE Profile's Smart Indoor Smoker
- America Ferrera Reveals How Kerry Washington Helped Her During Postpartum
- Pete Alonso's best free agent fits: Will Mets bring back Polar Bear?
- BPA, phthalates widespread in supermarket foods, regardless of packaging, Consumer Report says
- Washington state lawmakers to take on fentanyl and housing in Inslee’s final legislative session
- Anthony Joshua vs. Francis Ngannou boxing match set for March 9 in Saudi Arabia
- Taylor Swift's Dad Scott Swift Photobombs Couples Pic With Travis Kelce
- BPA, phthalates widespread in supermarket foods, regardless of packaging, Consumer Report says
Ranking
- Dick Van Dyke says he 'fortunately' won't be around for Trump's second presidency
- Virginia man keeps his word and splits his $230,000 lottery prize with his brother
- David Soul, who played Hutch in TV's Starsky and Hutch, dies at age 80
- B-1 bomber crashes while trying to land at its base in South Dakota, Air Force says
- Reese Witherspoon's Daughter Ava Phillippe Introduces Adorable New Family Member
- A drug cartel has attacked a remote Mexican community with drones and gunmen, rights group says
- J.Crew Outerwear, Sweaters & Boots Are an Extra 70% off & It's the Sale I've Been Dreaming About
- Hailey Bieber Shares Cheeky Glimpse Into Tropical Holiday Vacation With Husband Justin Bieber
Recommendation
-
2 weeks after Peanut the Squirrel's euthanasia, owner is seeking answers, justice
-
Justice Department sues Texas over state's new border security law
-
China calls for peaceful coexistence and promises pandas on the 45th anniversary of U.S.-China ties
-
Terminally ill Connecticut woman ends her life in Vermont
-
Judge weighs the merits of a lawsuit alleging ‘Real Housewives’ creators abused a cast member
-
New Jersey to allow teens who’ll be 18 by a general election to vote in primaries
-
Nikola Jokic delivers knockout blow to Steph Curry and the Warriors with epic buzzer beater
-
Defense Secretary Austin hospitalized due to complications after minor procedure